Arc Forumnew | comments | leaders | submitlogin
2 points by akkartik 1503 days ago | link | parent

The reason to use 'write rather than 'display is precisely so that things can be pasted into the repl. All you should have to do is 'read and 'eval the entire error string.

But there's definitely something busted about this. In anarki:

  arc> (= x "abc")
  arc> (err x)
  Error: "abc"           ; ok, looks good
  arc> (= x 'abc)
  arc> (err x)
  Error: "error: abc"    ; whaa..
There's also a long-standing issue that's bothered me before:

  arc> (= x "abc")
  arc> (err x " shouldn't be a string")
  Error: "abc \" shouldn't be a string\""
You're right, that's pretty ghastly. It should print:

  Error: "abc" shouldn't be a string
or:

  Error: "\"abc\" shouldn't be a string"
I'm still mulling what the culprit is here, but I don't think it's write vs display.


4 points by rocketnia 1503 days ago | link

The culprit is that 'err is defined to be Racket's 'error. It looks like every single use case of 'error is discouraged for one reason or another in the Racket reference:

http://docs.racket-lang.org/reference/exns.html#%28def._%28%...

- (error sym) creates a message string by concatenating "error: " with the string form of sym. Use this form sparingly.

- (error msg v ...) creates a message string by concatenating msg with string versions of the vs (as produced by the current error value conversion handler; see error-value->string-handler). A space is inserted before each v. Use this form sparingly, because it does not conform well to Racket’s error message conventions; consider raise-arguments-error, instead.

- (error src frmat v ...) creates a message string equivalent to the string created by

  (format (string-append "~s: " frmat) src v ...)
When possible, use functions such as raise-argument-error, instead, which construct messages that follow Racket’s error message conventions.

-----

2 points by rocketnia 1502 days ago | link

Er, I knew it was weird for me to say "'err is defined to be Racket's 'error," but I just realized, that factoid was in the original post of this thread. :-p

-----