Arc Forumnew | comments | leaders | submitlogin
2 points by Adlai 3105 days ago | link | parent

The return value should correspond to what was being searched for.

In other words, searching for one character should return an index, while searching for a substring should return a range.

There are thus four operations which would ideally be possible through ("abc" x):

  arc> (= str "hello arc!")
  "hello arc!"
  arc> (str "arc")
  6..8     ; or some other way of representing a range
  arc> (str #\!)
  9
  arc> (str 5)
  #\space
  arc> (str 4..7)   ; same as previous comment
  "o ar"
A way to take advantage of multiple values, if they were available, could be something like this:

  arc> (str #\l)
  2
  3


1 point by conanite 3105 days ago | link

Just curious - wouldn't it suffice to return the index of the beginning of the matched string when running a substring search?

  arc> (str "arc")
  6
, because you already know the length of "arc", so you don't really need a range result?

Otherwise, these are great ways to occupy the "semantic space" of string in fn position.

-----

1 point by shader 3105 days ago | link

I agree with you. I don't think that returning a range is necessary.

Even if call position and assignment weren't handled separately, it would still be possible to work off of the length of the argument and the index, without needing a range.

The question is whether or not pg agrees with us enough to add it to arc3 ;)

-----

1 point by conanite 3105 days ago | link

If there are 100 arc coders in the world, there are probably 100 versions of arc also. The question is whether you want it in your arc :)

-----

1 point by shader 3105 days ago | link

True. And I do. Unfortunately, I'm busy working on several other things at once right now. If you want to start working on it, be my guest. Hopefully I'll be able to share what I've been doing soon.

-----

1 point by Adlai 3105 days ago | link

I guess that (str "world") could just return an index, because (= (str "world") "arc") has access to the entire call, and can thus calculate

  (+ (str "world") (len "world"))
to figure out what the tail of the string should be after a substitution.

-----

1 point by shader 3105 days ago | link

Well, scheme supports multiple values, so it shouldn't be too hard to get them into arc, right?

-----

1 point by conanite 3105 days ago | link

arc supports multiple values via destructuring

  (let (a b c) (fn-returning-list-of-3-things)
    ...)
In the particular case of returning multiple indexes into a string though, you don't usually know in advance how many matches there will be, so destructuring isn't an option.

-----

1 point by Adlai 3105 days ago | link

Multiple return values from a form are allocated on the stack, not on the heap. I don't 100% understand what that means, though...

One practical consequence is that you don't have to deal with later multiple values if you don't want to, but when values are returned as a list, you have to deal with them.

-----